🎩 The Choice: 'Better Be... SLYTHERIN!'
A whisper. An unexpected choice. Hermione Granger’s first day at Hogwarts was meant to be the prologue to a legend—just not the one everyone knows. As the Sorting Hat settled over her bushy hair, a silent battle raged in her mind. “Gryffindor, please, Gryffindor,” she begged internally. But the old hat, perceiving layers of ambition, cunning, and a thirst for recognition she herself denied, responded with an unsettling calm: “No… better be… SLYTHERIN.” The Great Hall fell into a deathly silence. A Mudblood in the house of the pure-bloods. The first link in a chain of events that would completely redefine the destiny of the wizarding world.
1. 🐍 Surviving Slytherin: Earning Snape's Respect
The atmosphere was hostile from the start. Sneering looks, whispers in the corridors, and the constant challenge from Draco Malfoy, who couldn’t stand being outshone by a Muggle-born. But Hermione, with her trademark steel resolve, refused to break.
- Her weapon: Knowledge. She studied until dawn, mastered complex charms, and perfected potions with a precision even Severus Snape was forced to acknowledge.
- Her strategy: Earn respect, not with tears, but with flawless results. Slowly, her name became synonymous with excellence, even among Slytherin’s most skeptical pure-bloods.
- Her unexpected first ally: Snape himself, who saw in her brilliant, methodical mind a reflection of Lily Evans. He began to mentor her in secret, providing forbidden texts and challenging her with advanced alchemy.
2. 🧪 Snape's Secret Protégé
Their relationship wasn’t warm; it was rigorous, demanding, and deeply respectful. In Hermione, Snape found the pupil he always deserved: a keen mind unwilling to accept the status quo.
- Clandestine tutoring: Sessions after hours where they explored magic not in any curriculum.
- A common purpose: Snape, haunted by his past, began to see in her the possibility of a future where light and dark weren’t so clearly defined.
- The result: Under his tutelage, Hermione became not just the top student, but a strategic force. Slytherin won the House Cup year after year, thanks largely to her impeccable point gains.
3. 💔 The Butterfly Effect: A Weaker, Lonelier Harry
While Hermione flourished in the dungeons, things were very different in Gryffindor. Harry Potter, without his intellectual and moral compass, stumbled where he had once triumphed.
s - Without his guide: He failed to decipher the logic of the enchanted chessboard, was nearly bested by Quirrell, and emerged badly wounded from his encounter with the Philosopher’s Stone.
- A new loneliness: Harry felt the absence of a voice telling him to “stop and think.” His path grew darker and more solitary, despite Ron’s loyalty.
- Crossed paths: Hermione and Harry passed in the halls, but only with sharp glances and distant respect. She had learned she couldn’t carry the weight of others’ destinies.
4. ❤️🔥 From Rivalry to Respect: The Rise of Dramione
What began as pure contempt from Draco slowly burned into a curious obsession, and then into an inadmissible admiration. He could no longer deny that Hermione was extraordinary.
- The turning point: A Potions class where they were paired. Draco saw her compassion, her precision, and how she made him feel capable without humiliation.
- Stolen glances: They began to seek each other out in the library, their sharp banter laced with something new. The tension was palpable, magnetic.
- A love forged in fire: When Hermione was kidnapped by Death Eaters in their sixth year, Draco and Snape embarked on a desperate mission to save her. It was on this quest that Draco finally chose his side, defying his own lineage and Voldemort himself.
5. ⚔️ The War: A Victory Forged by a New Trio
Voldemort’s fall didn’t come at the hand of the Chosen One, but from an improbable trio: A brilliant witch, a redeemed spy, and a boy who chose love over hate.
Screen - The strategy: Using intelligence extracted from Horcruxes, they laid a trap for the Dark Lord and destroyed him with his own dark magic.
- The cost: Hermione was left physically and mentally scarred, but alive. Draco, having renounced everything for her, found his true redemption.
- The ending: They married in an intimate ceremony, with Snape as their witness. They raised their children away from old prejudices, as the wizarding world rebuilt itself under a new light.
Music
🔮 Conclusion: A Hero Forged in Darkness?
This alternate reality poses a deeply intriguing question: Does power corrupt or liberate? Hermione, far from being corrupted by Slytherin’s ambition, used that same ambition to reform the house from within, redeem a Malfoy, and change the war’s outcome. Her story isn’t that of a heroine born into the light, but of a warrior who carved her path through the darkness and, from there, lit up everything around her. It proves that our choices, not our destiny, forge who we are.
> 📣 What do you think? Would this version have been better than the original? Would Hermione have become the most powerful witch or a fearsome villain? Sound off in the comments!